WMU football

Last year the Broncos had fumbling issues with snaps. This year, the issues are on Kaleb Eleby himself as he has coughed up the ball several times on scrambles.

Head coach Tim Lester and the Western Michigan football team faltered in yet another close-scoring late-game setting Tuesday night, ultimately losing to in-state rival Eastern Michigan by a score of 22-21. Here are the key takeaways from the Broncos’ fifth loss of the season:

Eleby’s ball security needs to improve

Kaleb Eleby was, for the most part, a huge bright spot for WMU in the loss. Before the fourth quarter game-sealing interception, the redshirt sophomore was nothing short of incredible as he threw for 307 yards on 22 of 29 passes with a score through the air and on the ground.

Eleby made a crucial mistake in the fourth quarter though, coughing up the ball late on a hit by the Eagle’s Turan Rush which eventually led to the game-winning score on a field goal from Chad Ryland. Turnovers as a whole have been a problem lately for WMU, but Eleby’s inability to take a hit and secure the football has been troubling.

Defense couldn't get off of the field

One of the keys Western Michigan needed to keep in mind coming into the contest was a need to keep Eastern Michigan’s offense from converting on third and fourth downs. Lou Esposito’s unit was unable to achieve that goal, as they allowed three conversions on fourth down from the Eagles, a perfect conversion rate from EMU on the night.

Too many times the Bronco defense has taken the ‘bend don’t break’ approach, and it has burned the 6-5 squad every game, whether it be through deep plays or allowing teams to get into field goal range. Eastern Michigan was 5-5 on field goal attempts on the night, which is an incredibly accurate line, but WMU needed to not allow the Eagles to have five field goal attempts in the first place.

Tim Lester is officially on the hot seat

With yet another loss in November, the ‘Lester Letdown’ phenomenon becomes more and more real. The Western Michigan football program consistently puts itself in position to secure wins early and midway through contests, but questionable play calling and coaching decisions have once again bogged down the Broncos late in the season. Now supporters of the program are calling for his head, a growing theme over the last two seasons.

With athletic director Kathy Beauregard on her way out, it seems that Lester will have one more year to leave a lasting impression on the WMU fanbase and the Mid-American Conference before the next AD decides his fate. The young head coach has had plenty of talent and holdovers from the PJ Fleck years to work with, and it seems that this team comes up short in almost every situation and repeatedly disappoints its fans.

(1) comment


I have been a staunch supporter of Coach Lester, applauding his hire 5 years ago. A fan too of his stellar play in the late 90s for WMU. Currently, I have to believe the program is floundering admist 2nd half and redzone calamities. Plus, a place kicking debacle that has been a significant thorn. This year was touted as '4' as in winning MAC for the fourth time. Everyone must have believed that was possible with talent returning, albeit without D Eskridge.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.